Opinion: AI Will Not Replace College Writing Instructors
The Role of Writing Instructors in the Age of AI
As technology evolves, many have raised concerns about the potential impact of tools like ChatGPT on various professions, including college writing instructors. Critics often claim that AI will make these educators obsolete. Yet, these claims overlook the fundamental aspects of teaching writing that AI cannot replicate. Rather than viewing AI as a threat, writing instructors must recognize what sets their role apart.
Understanding Persona in Writing
One key element that quality writing embodies is persona. Good writing is more than just clear communication; it channels a distinct voice and identity. Students need to learn how to craft a writing style that captures attention and resonates with readers.
When students engage with the works of iconic authors like Oscar Wilde, Frederick Douglass, or Octavia Butler, they’re not just reading—they’re experiencing the unique voices that these writers crafted. Wilde famously noted, “The first task in life is to assume a pose.” This statement captures the essence of developing a strong persona in writing.
- Power of Persona: A well-developed voice can influence how a reader perceives the writer. Students aspire to create a persona that reflects their thoughts and values. This transformative process is something that AI lacks the ability to comprehend or convey.
The Importance of Ideas
Equally important in teaching writing is the focus on big, thought-provoking ideas. Instructors uncover and cultivate the power of ideas that can inspire, challenge, and provoke deeper discussions among students. Understanding complex concepts is crucial for developing a nuanced approach to writing.
For instance:
- Bread and Circuses: This idea refers to the way society often distracts the masses with trivial concerns, and it can lead to engaging discussions about societal issues.
- Nihilism: Delving into this philosophy offers students a platform to explore themes of meaning and existence, often leading to vibrant debates.
- Rousseau’s Concepts: The contrast between the “noble savage” and human arrogance prompts critical thinking about human nature and ethics.
AI tools like ChatGPT tend to recycle existing language and ideas without offering true originality. In contrast, effective instructors present students with the thrill of exploring significant, often messy ideas, igniting intellectual curiosity and passion.
Navigating Chaos in the Writing Process
Today’s students face a barrage of distractions in their daily lives, making focus and discipline increasingly challenging. Writing instructors play a vital role in guiding students to combat this chaos. Teaching techniques such as focused writing sessions and strategies for "deep work," as advocated by thinkers like Cal Newport, helps students cultivate the mental resilience needed for writing.
- Resilience and Discipline: Well-known writers and educators like Oliver Burkeman and Angela Duckworth provide frameworks that can help students strengthen their perseverance. These frameworks encourage students to push through distractions and deeply engage with their writing.
Unlike AI, which can generate text without understanding the human experience, instructors can foster habits that build character and determination among students.
The Transformative Role of Instructors
Ultimately, writing instructors are not merely teaching technical skills; they are shaping thinkers, debaters, and future leaders. While tools like ChatGPT can assist with generating text, they cannot replace the invaluable mentorship and guidance that educators provide.
The task of teaching writing encompasses much more than language mechanics; it involves nurturing individual voices, encouraging deep thinking, and helping students navigate the complexities of their thoughts and feelings. Writing instructors are architects of intellectual growth, positioning students to engage with the world in a meaningful way.
